| Name | Cause of death | Killer | Notes |
|
Jess |
Pulled underwater and eaten | Thresher shark | Was mentioned by sheriff Sabin As he was just about to dunk Nick In the water with a tiger shark. |
| Maya | Knocked off Boat into water, grabbed and eaten | Bull shark | |
| Gordon | Bitten in stomach/Yanked off Tree branch and eaten | Bull Shark | Forced into water |
| Beth | Bitten all over body/Face/drowned in the water | Dennis, Red, Cookie Cutter Shark's | Pushed into water |
| Malik | Drowned/Eaten | Mako Shark | Sacrificed, Jumped off jet ski boat |
| Blake | Plucked off jet ski boat into water/eaten | Great White Shark | Head but off |
| Sherrif Sabin | Burned, fell into shark pool/ eaten | Nick, Tiger Sharks | Lit on fire by Nick, forcing him to go in the water with the Tiger Shark |
| Red | Knife thrown into chest, drowned in water | Dennis | Betrayed |
| Dennis | Ripped apart/eaten | Sara, Great white shark | Handcuffed to the Shark Cage |